, ,

Thinking About Coloring Your Natural Hair? Weigh the Pros and Cons First.

6:00 AM

Thinking About Coloring Your Natural Hair? Weigh the Pros and Cons First.

One of the many reasons that inspires me to keep The Mane Objective going is the mere hope that someone, somewhere can learn something from my journey. Replicate my successes, gain an informed perspective on products, and avoid my mistakes like the plague.

This article is something like the latter. Now, I'm not saying that dyeing my hair was a mistake. Although to be quite honest, if I could do it all over again, I wouldn't. This is not an indictment of Carleen (who did a fab color job that I get complimented on all the time), but rather an honest reflection of living the dye life. But you live and you learn, right?  Before I get too far in to my own personal musings on hair color, let me get to the heart of the matter at hand. 

Deciding to dye your natural hair can be thrilling and fun, or a complete pain in the kituckus. There are some definite benefits and drawbacks to the process. But before you pick up that box of dye or book a salon appointment, there are some serious factors that should be taken into consideration. Prior to taking the color plunge, consider the following list of (my personal) pros and cons:

Pros of Hair Color

1. It's a New Look!
The thought of adding a little flair to your hair is exciting. Hair color is a relatively painless way to give you and your hair a new attitude. Go dark, go light, go ombre, go mermaid, go highlights -- the possibilities are quite literally endless, and when you have a talented colorist behind you, a great dye job can highlight your natural beauty.

2. Hair Color Adds Dimension
When my hair was dark, I felt like the color fell flat, and the depth/thickness was difficult to capture because my hair was pretty much all one color. With a custom dye job, although my hair is red, there are highlights, lowlights, and everything in-between that has given my hair vibrancy and dimension. 

3. Natural Hair is the Ideal Hair
Some may fight me on this one, but from a hair integrity standpoint, natural hair is the perfect hair type to work on for a dye job. Hair that has not been previously damaged via heat or chemical process (whether it be relaxer or other dye) has a greater chance of withstanding the chemical changes the hair undergoes in the coloring process. Although some getting hair dyed may experience difficulty in uptake of dye (due to tightly compacted chemicals/low porosity hair), this is still infinitely better than previously damaged hair that breaks down with that same exposure.


Thinking About Coloring Your Natural Hair? Weigh the Pros and Cons First.
My dark versus light hair. Which one do you like more?
Cons of Hair Color

1. It's Customized Damage. Period.
I once read somewhere (I think it was a blog that belonged to a stylist/colorist) that hair dye is customized damage. I wish I had known that before I got my hair colored. I'm a firm believer that straight talk makes for good understanding, and this is about as straightforward as it gets. Dye will change your hair. In the process of lifting melanin (because that's what bleaches and ammonia do) from the hair and depositing color into it, cuticles have to be lifted, which can cause all sorts of issues from changes in porosity to weakening of the structural integrity of the strand. These issues can lead to curls going limp, drying out, breaking, or a combination of all 3. Which leads me to con #2...

2. Color Requires an Entirely NEW Regimen
Admittedly, this threw me for the BIGGEST loop. I didn't think I'd have to start building my regimen from scratch -- especially after I had already pretty much figured out what my hair liked and didn't like. Quite literally, everything I thought I knew about my hair went out the window. As it turns out, I'm not the only person with this experience. If the process of re-learning your hair is unappealing, this is definitely something to consider.


3. Your Hair Will Be Lackluster (Literally.)
Making my hair shine while it was dark was pretty much a walk in the park. After my dye job, I have been having a dickens of a time getting the natural luster I used to have come through. I can use the same product to add shine to my roots and length, and my roots will look shiny and glorious, while the dyed length will remain....underwhelming. Dark hair shines more and appears healthier, while color treated hair is dull and lacks vibrancy. Dyed hair impacts the cuticle layer of the hair, which impacts porosity, which impacts shine. 

Well, those are my 6 pros and cons -- solely based on my experience. In the beginning, I stated that if I had to do it all over again, I wouldn't have dyed my hair. Why? Although I love the red and get tons of compliments, the upkeep gives me night terrors. I'm a low-maintenance kind of gal, and juggling protein treatments with extra moisturizing deep conditioners, and counting the number of times I co-wash before shampooing can be a bit much, even for me. Not to mention throwing in my regular henna treatments, and trying to keep my hair decently moisturized. On that note, thank God for Be Kekoa Be Clean and Mud Rinses. Y'all the real MVPs.

Kevin Durant You The Real MVP
Even KD thinks so.
Are you considering the color plunge this spring? If so, what are some of your concerns? Let me know in the comments below!

You Might Also Like

13 comments

  1. Christina, I hope you will forgive my language here, but.....I FUCKING LOVE your blog. LOVE. I swear every day you put up a post about EXACTLY what I am going through with my hair. I have been threatening to dye my hair red for YEARS now, and finally decided to take the plunge! Like RED. I have colored it before, so I do know how to approach it this time. Love your pros and cons - especially about your hair changing. I had no idea last time around, but for sure I'm going to show my hair much more TLC with this color. Thank you, thank you for the content of this blog - it REALLY speaks to me.

    ReplyDelete
  2. OMG.... THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! You have no idea how comments like yours make me happy and keep me going. I'm so glad that I can be helpful. Let me know how your red comes out!!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have a question for you, do you think I should dye my hair dark pink? I'm a 13 year old male and one of my favorite youtubers did it, so I'm thinking about doing it. Do you have any tips?

    ReplyDelete
  4. This was SO helpful!! I've been contemplating going red for a while and you just helped me make my decision! Thanks for blogging on this! ❤️

    ReplyDelete
  5. After reading this "blog" I realized how bs the reasons people dye their hair give. So let me get this straight, if you get bored with your own appearence, change the color of your hair? How self-conscious does one have to be to the point where they feel the need to get what you claim to be "excitement" with their own hair color? I have no problem with people dying their hair but when the pros and cons lye specifically around feeling pretty, it makes it seem like you don't have enough positive people around you in life. I feel as though you lack the logos to be typing this up.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My bad, I said logos. I meant to say ethos

      Delete
    2. You are reading to much into it Anon. What's wrong with getting bored of your natural hair color if you've had it same thing your entire life. A color is change to spice things about changes are inherently exciting. Just because someone gets excited about a new hair color doesn't mean they have low self esteem.

      Delete
  6. I have natural dirty blonde (light brown) hair, with natural highlights here and there, I keep going through phases of wanting to dye it a certain colour, it's so frustrating. At the moment I want to dye it black. Is it worth it? If I use a semi permanent dye, will I be able to get my natural colour back?

    ReplyDelete
  7. This generation has had a serious problem of getting grey hair at an early age and it is just increasing. All of this happens because of our lifestyle, eating habits, stress and chemicals in the products we use. Getting your hair dyed is not healthy for your hair and since I am going through the same problem of having grey hair so early I decided to find a safe and healthy solution. I came across Kama Ayurveda's organic henna powder and indigo powder and this combination has saved me! It is the organic way to go and dyes your hair black, I have been using these products for several months now and am so happy. Everyone who is having this same problem, I highly recommend to use such products rather than hair dye.
    http://www.posherry.com/blog/kama-ayurveda-solves-white-hair-problems/

    ReplyDelete
  8. This generation has had a serious problem of getting grey hair at an early age and it is just increasing. All of this happens because of our lifestyle, eating habits, stress and chemicals in the products we use. Getting your hair dyed is not healthy for your hair and since I am going through the same problem of having grey hair so early I decided to find a safe and healthy solution. I came across Kama Ayurveda's organic henna powder and indigo powder and this combination has saved me! It is the organic way to go and dyes your hair black, I have been using these products for several months now and am so happy. Everyone who is having this same problem, I highly recommend to use such products rather than hair dye.
    http://www.posherry.com/blog/kama-ayurveda-solves-white-hair-problems/

    ReplyDelete
  9. This generation has had a serious problem of getting grey hair at an early age and it is just increasing. All of this happens because of our lifestyle, eating habits, stress and chemicals in the products we use. Getting your hair dyed is not healthy for your hair and since I am going through the same problem of having grey hair so early I decided to find a safe and healthy solution. I came across Kama Ayurveda's organic henna powder and indigo powder and this combination has saved me! It is the organic way to go and dyes your hair black, I have been using these products for several months now and am so happy. Everyone who is having this same problem, I highly recommend to use such products rather than hair dye.
    http://www.posherry.com/blog/kama-ayurveda-solves-white-hair-problems/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Nice post. I used to be checking continuously this blog and I am inspired! Very helpful info specially the last part. I take care of such information much. blonde hair

    ReplyDelete